Beyond Chapala and Cancún: Grappling with the Impact of American Migration to Mexico

Resumen

Over the past two decades, a twist in the migratory relationship between Mexico and the United States has begun to attract the attention of policy makers and scholars: a growing stream of people moving permanently or semi-permanently from the United States to Mexico. Th e general understanding of this phenomenon until recently has been that these migrants are wealthy retirees moving to isolated resort-type complexes in beach cities. However, the present paper demonstrates that the migration is actually heterogeneous in terms of its people, places and impacts.Thus, we argue that study of the phenomenon must be expanded to include not only a better understanding of the migrants themselves, but also the impacts on the receiving localities. To this end, we propose a framework for a research agenda, creating a typology of receiving places and the settlements within these places.Más allá de Chapala y Cancún: Lidiando con el impacto de la migración estadounidense en MéxicoResumenA lo largo de las dos últimas décadas, un viraje en la relación migratoria entre México y Estados Unidos ha comenzado a captar el interés de políticos e investigadores: se trata del flujo en el aumento de estadounidenses que se trasladan a vivir a México de manera temporal o permanente. Hasta hace poco, la interpretación general de este fenómeno era que se trataba de migrantes jubilados y solventes que se dirigían a centros turísticos exclusivos en diversas ciudades costeras. Este trabajo pone de manifiesto que esta migración es en extremo heterogénea en cuanto a las personas, los destinos y sus efectos.Además argumenta que el análisis de este fenómeno debería enfocarse no sólo en los migrantes sino también en el impacto del flujo migratorio sobre las localidades receptoras. Con este fin, se propone un esquema para una nueva línea de investigación con una tipología de las localidades receptoras y sus asentamientos. Esta tipología nos permite acceder a la literatura académica para la investigación de la migración de estadounidenses a México.

Imagen de portada

Palabras clave

• retirement migration
• urban planning
• tourism geographies
• Mexico
• United States

Cómo citar

Citas

1. Álvarez-Rivadulla, M. J., 2007, “Golden Ghettos: Gated Communities
2. and Class Residential Segregation in Montevideo, Uruguay”,
3. Environment and Planning A, vol. 39, num. 1, pp. 47-63.
4. American Citizens Abroad (aca), 1999, “Myths and Facts: Including
5. Americans Abroad in Census 2000”. Available at
6. www.aca.ch/mythfac.htm> (last accessed on July 19, 2009).
7. Andelson, R. V., 2000, “Land-value Taxation around the World”,
8. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, vol. 59, num. 5,
9. Supplement, p. 490.
10. Banks, S. P., 2004, “Identity Narratives by American and Canadian
11. Retirees in Mexico”, Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology,
12. vol. 19, num. 4, December, pp. 361-381.
13. Bosque, R. L., and V. Z. Montes de Oca Zavala [conference],
14. , “Análisis comparado de la migración internacional de
15. vejez hacia España y México”, ii Congreso de la Asociación
16. Latinoamericana de Población, Guadalajara, Mexico, September
17. -5.
18. Brenner, L., 2005, “State-planned Tourism Destinations: The
19. Case of Huatulco, Mexico”, Tourism Geographies, vol. 7, num.
20. , pp. 138-164.
21. Brenner, L. and A. G. Aguilar, 2002, “Luxury Tourism and Regional
22. Economic Development in Mexico”, The Professional
23. Geographer, vol. 54, num. 4, pp. 500-520.
24. Caldeira, T. P. R., 2000, City of Walls: Crime, Segregation, and
25. Citizenship in São Paulo, Berkeley, California, University of
26. California Press.
27. Chicago Graduate School of Business News, 2007, “Mexican-U.S.
28. Migration could Flow Both Ways”, Chicago GSB News, Chicago,
29. Illinois, The University of Chicago Booth School of Business,
30. June 14. Available at
31. -14_carstens.aspx> (last accessed on June 14, 2007).
32. Clancy, M. J., 1999, “Tourism and Development Evidence from
33. Mexico”, Annals of Tourism Research, vol. 26, num. 1, pp. 1-20.
34. Clancy, M. J., 2000, “Mexican Tourism: Export Growth and
35. Structural Change since 1970”, Latin American Research Review,
36. vol. 36, num 1, pp. 128-150.
37. Coates, K. S., R. Healy and W. R. Morrison, 2002, “Tracking the
38. Snowbirds: Seasonal Migration from Canada to the USA and
39. Mexico”, American Review of Canadian Studies, vol. 32, num.
40. , pp. 433-452.
41. Collins, J. L., 2003, Threads: Gender, Labor, and Power in the
42. Global Apparel Industry, Chicago, Illinois, University of Chicago
43. Press.
44. Croucher, S., 2007, “‘They Love Us Here’: American Migrants
45. in Mexico”, Dissent, Winter. Available at
46. dissentmagazine.org/article/?article=723> (last accessed on July
47. , 2009).
48. Dalsgaard, T., 2000, The Tax System in Mexico: A Need for
49. Strength ening the Revenue-Raising Capacity, Paris, Organisation
50. for Economic Co-operation and Development [ECO/
51. WKP(2000)6. Unclassified].
52. Davis, M., 2006, “Mexico’s Immigration Problem (Excerpt ed from
53. no one Is Illegal)”, TomPaine.Com. Available at
54. tompaine.com/articles/2006/09/25/mexicos_immigration_
55. problem.php> (last accessed on September 25, 2006).
56. De Duren, N. L., 2006, “Planning à la carte: The Location Patterns
57. of Gated Communities around Buenos Aires in a Decentralized
58. Planning Context”, International Journal of Urban and
59. Regional Research, vol. 30, num. 2, pp. 308-327.
60. Dear, M. and A. Burridge, 2005, “Cultural Integration and Hybridization
61. in the United States-Mexico Borderlands”, Cahiers
62. de Géographie du Québec, vol. 49, num. 138, pp. 301-318.
63. Dear, M. J. and G. Leclerc, eds., 2003, Postborder City: Cultural
64. Spaces of Bajalta California”, New York, Routledge.
65. Dibble, S., 2002, “Foreigners could Lose Oceanfront Residences
66. in Mexico; Southern Baja Homes Violating Coastal Law”, The
67. San Diego Union-Tribune, San Diego, California, April 3, p.
68. B1, 2002.
69. Dibble, S. and L. Weisberg, 2005, “Baja’s Building Boom”, Copley
70. News Service, San Diego, California. Available at
71. signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20051002/news_1n2rush.
72. html> (last accessed on October 3, 2005).
73. Dove J., 2007, “Tourist Impact on the Yucatán Peninsula”, Geography
74. Review, vol. 20, num. 5, pp. 2-4.
75. Enríquez Acosta, J. Á., 2008, “Segregación y fragmentación en las
76. nuevas ciudades para el turismo: Caso Puerto Peñasco, Sonora,
77. México”, Topofilia, vol. 1, num. 1. Available at
78. net/enriquez.html> (last accessed on July 19, 2009).
79. Everitt, J. et al., 2008, “The Imprints of Tourism on Puerto
80. Vallarta, Jalisco, Mexico”, Canadian Geographer/Le Geographe
81. Canadien, vol. 52, num. 1, pp. 83-104.
82. Freeman, L., 2006, There Goes the Hood: Views of Gentrification
83. from the Ground up, Philadelphia, Temple University Press.
84. Freeman, L. and F. Braconi, 2004, “Gentrification and Displacement:
85. New York City in the 1990’s”, Journal of the American
86. Planning Association, vol. 70, num. 1, pp. 39-52.
87. Gereffi, G., J. Humphrey and T. Sturgeon, 2005, “The Governance
88. of Global Value Chains”, Review of International Political
89. Economy, vol. 12, num. 1, pp. 78-104.
90. Gullette, G. S., 2007, “Development Economics, Developing Migration:
91. Targeted Economic Development Initiatives as Drivers
92. in International Migration”, Human Organization, vol. 66,
93. num. 4, pp. 366-379.
94. Hackworth, J., 2002, “Postrecession Gentrification in New York
95. City”, Urban Affairs Review, vol. 37, num. 6, pp. 815-843.
96. Hawley, C., 2007, “Seniors Head to Mexico for Cheaper Nursing
97. Care: Despite Quality Concerns, Prices Prove Appealing”, The
98. Arizona Republic, August 16.
99. Herzog, L., 2003, “Global Tijuana: The Seven Ecologies of the
100. Border”, in M. J. Dear and G. Leclerc, eds., Postborder City:
101. Cultural Spaces of Bajalta California, New York, Routledge, pp.
102. -142.
103. Holder, V. H., 1976, The Migration of Retirees to Mexico, a Survey
104. and Case Study of Guadalajara, Mexico, Minneapolis, Minnesota,
105. University of Minnesota.
106. Holguin, Jaime, 2004, “More Retirees Migrating South: Growing
107. Stream of Americans Running to Mexico”, CBS Evening
108. News, Playas de Rosarito, Mexico, May 19, 2004. Available at
109. <http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2004/05/19/eveningnews/
110. main618600.shtml> (last accessed on May 1, 2011).
111. inegi, 1999, Censos económicos 1999, Aguascalientes, Mexico, Instituto
112. Nacional de Estadística y Geografía. Available at
113. www.inegi.org.mx/est/contenidos/espanol/proyectos/censos/
114. ce1999/saic/default.asp?modelo=CMAP&s=est&c=10354>
115. (last accessed on May 10, 2011).
116. Inegi, 2001, XII Censo general de población y vivienda 2000, Aguascalientes, Mexico, Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía.
117. Johnson, R., 2007, “Taking Baja South”, Los Angeles Times,
118. Los Angeles, October 14. Available at <http://articles.latimes.
119. com/2007/oct/14/magazine/tm-bajaboom28> (last accessed on
120. July 19, 2009).
121. Kincannon, C. L., 2004, “Counting Americans Overseas: Lessons
122. Learned from the 2004 Overseas Enumeration Test”,
123. U.S. Census Bureau, U.S. House of Representatives, September
125. Lizárraga Morales, O., 2008a, “La inmigración de jubilados estadounidenses en México y sus prácticas transnacionales: Estudio
126. de caso en Mazatlán, Sinaloa y Cabo San Lucas, Baja
127. California Sur”, Migración y Desarrollo, num. 11, pp. 97-117.
128. Lizárraga Morales, O., 2008b, “Los inmigrantes estadounidenses
129. en Mazatlán y Los Cabos”, Arenas: Revista Sinaloense de Ciencias
130. Sociales, num. 16, pp. 103-115.
131. Lizárraga Morales, O., 2010, “The U.S. Citizens’ Retirement Migration
132. to Los Cabos, Mexico”, Recreation and Society in Africa,
133. Asia, & Latin America (RASALA), vol. 1, num. 1, pp. 75-92.
134. López-López, A., 2006, “Segregation of Tourist Space in Los Cabos,
135. Mexico”, Tourism Geographies, vol. 8, num. 4, pp. 359-379.
136. Lucero, H. M., 2003, “Peopling Baja California”, in M. J. Dear
137. and G. Leclerc, eds., 2003, Postborder City: Cultural Spaces of
138. Bajalta California, New York, Routledge.
139. Migration Policy Institute (mpi), 2006, America’s Emigrants: U.S.
140. Retirement Migration to Mexico and Panama. Available at
141. <http://www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs/americas_emigrants.
142. php> (last accessed on July 19, 2009).
143. Newman, K. and E. Wyly, 2006, “The Right to Stay Put, Revisited:
144. Gentrification and Resistance to Displacement in New
145. York City”, Urban Studies, vol. 43, num. 1, pp. 23-57.
146. Otero, Y. and L. Melton, 1997, “U.S. Retired Persons in Mexico”,
147. American Behavioral Scientist, vol. 40, num. 7, p. 914.
148. Pender, K., 2007, “Tales of Buying Property South of the Bord -
149. er”, San Francisco Chronicle, San Francisco, California,
150. November 11. Available at <http://articles.sfgate.com/2007-
151. -11/business/17268094_1_panama-central-america-healthcare>
152. (last accessed on July 19, 2009).
153. Pírez, P., 2002, “Buenos Aires: Fragmentation and Privatization
154. of the Metropolitan City”, Environment and Urbanization, vol.
155. , num. 1, April, p. 145.
156. Plotnicov, L., 1994, “El atractivo de ciudades medias”, Estudios
157. Demográficos y Urbanos, vol. 9, num. 2, pp. 283-301.
158. Rodríguez, V. E., 1997, Decentralization in Mexico: From Reforma
159. Municipal to Solidaridad to Nuevo Federalismo, Boulder,
160. Colorado, Westview Press.
161. Roy, A. and N. AlSayyad, 2004, Urban Informality: Transnational
162. Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South
163. Asia, Lanham, Maryland, Lexington Books.
164. Sadowski-Smith, C., 2002, Globalization on the Line: Culture,
165. Capital, and Citizenship at U.S. borders, New York, Palgrave
166. Macmillan.
167. Smith, N., 1996, The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the
168. Revanchist City, New York, Routledge.
169. Smith, N. and P. Williams, 1986, Gentrification of the City, Boston,
170. Massachusetts, Allen & Unwin.
171. Steinitz, C. et al., 2005, “Alternative Futures for the Region of
172. Loreto, Baja California Sur, Mexico”, report from Harvard
173. University’s Graduate School of Design/Universidad Autónoma
174. de Baja California Sur/University of Arizona/cibnor/San
175. Die go State University/Scripps Institute of Oceanography/Municipality
176. of Loreto, B. C. S., November 17.
177. Stokes, E. M., 1990, “Ethnography of a Social Border: The Case
178. of an American Retirement Community in Mexico”, Journal of
179. Cross-Cultural Gerontology, vol. 5, num. 2, pp. 169-182.
180. Sunil, T. S., V. Rojas and D. E. Bradley, 2007, “United States’
181. International Retirement Migration: The Reasons for Retiring
182. to the Environs of Lake Chapala, Mexico”, Ageing and Society,
183. vol. 27, num. 04, pp. 489-510.
184. Svampa, M., 2001, Los que ganaron. La vida en los countries y barrios
185. privados, Buenos Aires, Biblos.
186. Tamborini, C. R., 2007, “Work, Wages and Gender in Export-
187. Oriented Cities: Global Assembly versus International Tourism
188. in Mexico”, Bulletin of Latin American Research, vol. 26, num.
189. , pp. 24-49.
190. Torres R. and J. Momsen, 2005a, “Planned Tourism Development
191. in Quintana Roo, Mexico: Engine for Regional Development
192. or Prescription for Inequitable Growth?”, Current Issues
193. in Tourism, vol. 8, num. 4, pp. 259-285.
194. Torres R. and J. Momsen, 2005b, “Gringolandia: The Construction
195. of a New Tourist Space in Mexico”, Annals of the Association
196. of American Geographers, vol. 95, num. 2, pp. 314-335.
197. Truly, D., 2002, “International Retirement Migration and Tourism
198. along the Lake Chapala Riviera: Developing a Matrix of
199. Retirement Migration Behaviour”, Tourism Geographies, vol. 4,
200. num. 3, pp. 261-281.
201. U.S. Census Bureau, 2006, American Community Survey. Available
202. at (last accessed on November
203. , 2007).
204. Ward, P. M., 2004, “Informality of Housing Production at the
205. Urban-Rural Interface: The Not-so-Strange Case of the Texas
206. Colonias”, in R. Ananya and N. AlSayyad, eds., Urban Informality:
207. Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin
208. America, and South Asia, Lanham, Maryland, Lexington
209. Books, pp. 243-270.
210. Warner, D. C. and L. R. Jahnke, 2001, “Toward Better Access to
211. Health Insurance Coverage for U.S. Retirees in Mexico”, Salud
212. Pública de México, vol. 43, num. 1, pp. 59-66.
213. Warnes, A. M., 2001, “The International Dispersal of Pensioners
214. from Affluent Countries”, International Journal of Population
215. Geography, vol. 7, num 5, pp. 373-388.
216. Wilson, T. D., 2008, “Economic and Social Impacts of Tourism
217. in Mexico”, Latin American Perspectives, vol. 35, num. 3, p. 37.